Watches like the Rolex Submariner for less

By Dave Kowalski, Chicago ยท Updated

The Rolex Submariner is the watch everybody pictures when you say "dive watch." It's also around ten grand at the dealer, if the dealer will sell you one, and that's before you get to the date version. So here's what you can buy instead, sorted from closest to the real thing down to the cheapest, with an honest note on what you give up.

First, the benchmark and my top pick side by side.

Rolex Submariner No Date

Reference
124060
Style
Diver
Case diameter
41 mm
Thickness
12.5 mm
Case material
Steel
Crystal
Sapphire
Movement
Automatic (3230)
Power reserve
70 hours
Complications
rotating bezel
Water resistance
300 m
Strap or bracelet
Metal
Released
2020
List price
$9,300 to $9,650

Tudor Black Bay 58

Reference
M79030N-0001
Style
Diver
Case diameter
39 mm
Thickness
11.9 mm
Case material
Steel
Crystal
Sapphire
Movement
Automatic (MT5402)
Power reserve
70 hours
Complications
rotating bezel
Water resistance
200 m
Strap or bracelet
Metal
Released
2018
List price
$4,325 to $4,600

The alternatives

1. Tudor Black Bay 58: Closest to the real thing

Reference
M79030N-0001
Style
Diver
Case diameter
39 mm
Thickness
11.9 mm
Case material
Steel
Crystal
Sapphire
Movement
Automatic (MT5402)
Power reserve
70 hours
Complications
rotating bezel
Water resistance
200 m
Strap or bracelet
Metal
Released
2018
List price
$4,325 to $4,600

Same parent company as Rolex, same idea, around half the price. 39 mm, so a bit smaller than the modern Sub, and a vintage style with a gold-toned dial print. The bezel insert is aluminium, not ceramic, and it's 200 m, not 300. Real talk though: on the wrist, nobody but a watch nerd will know you saved four or five grand.

2. Longines HydroConquest 41: Best for the money

Reference
L3.781.4.56.6
Style
Diver
Case diameter
41 mm
Thickness
11.9 mm
Case material
Steel
Crystal
Sapphire
Movement
Automatic (L888.5)
Power reserve
72 hours
Complications
date, rotating bezel
Water resistance
300 m
Strap or bracelet
Metal
Released
2018
List price
$1,650 to $1,900

This is my sleeper pick. 41 mm like the Sub, ceramic bezel like the Sub, 300 m like the Sub, a 72-hour movement and a Swiss brand older than Rolex, all for a fraction of the price. The looks are close without being a copy. If someone asked me for the most Submariner per dollar, I'd send them here.

3. Oris Aquis Date 41.5: Best independent brand

Reference
01 733 7766 4135-07 8 22 05PEB
Style
Diver
Case diameter
41.5 mm
Thickness
12.7 mm
Case material
Steel
Crystal
Sapphire
Movement
Automatic (Oris 733 (Sellita SW200-1))
Power reserve
38 hours
Complications
date, rotating bezel
Water resistance
300 m
Strap or bracelet
Metal
Released
2020
List price
$2,300 to $2,500

Oris is one of the last independent Swiss watchmakers, which some people care about a lot. The Aquis is 41.5 mm, 300 m, ceramic bezel, with chunkier, more modern lugs than the Rolex. It's its own watch, not a homage, which I like.

4. Christopher Ward C60 Trident Pro 300: Best under $1,500

Reference
C60-40ADA3-S00K0-B0
Style
Diver
Case diameter
40 mm
Thickness
11.5 mm
Case material
Steel
Crystal
Sapphire
Movement
Automatic (Sellita SW200-1)
Power reserve
38 hours
Complications
date, rotating bezel
Water resistance
300 m
Strap or bracelet
Metal
Released
2022
List price
$995 to $1,150

Right around a thousand bucks for 300 m, ceramic, sapphire and a 40 mm case that's actually thinner than the Rolex. The British brand sells direct, so you skip the dealer markup. The movement is a basic Swiss Sellita with 38 hours, which is the main place you notice the price.

5. Lorier Neptune: Best vintage Sub look

Reference
NEP5-BLK-ND-BRAC
Style
Diver
Case diameter
39 mm
Thickness
11.4 mm
Case material
Steel
Crystal
Sapphire
Movement
Automatic (Miyota 9039)
Power reserve
42 hours
Complications
rotating bezel
Water resistance
200 m
Strap or bracelet
Metal
Released
2025
List price
$700

If what you love is the 1960s Submariner, not the modern one, this is the watch. 39 mm, 11.4 mm, a warm vintage-style dial, no date. It nails the old look for well under a thousand dollars.

6. Invicta Pro Diver 8926OB: Cheapest

Reference
8926OB
Style
Diver
Case diameter
40 mm
Thickness
14 mm
Case material
Steel
Crystal
Mineral
Movement
Automatic (Seiko NH35A)
Power reserve
41 hours
Complications
date, rotating bezel
Water resistance
200 m
Strap or bracelet
Metal
Released
2009
List price
$80 to $130

Yeah, I'm including it. It costs about a hundred dollars, it has a reliable Seiko movement, and it's been the go-to "Sub look for no money" watch for years. Mineral crystal, so-so bezel, and it's a straight-up homage, which some people hate. But it's a real automatic diver that'll keep going, and you'll never worry about scratching it.

What you actually give up

  • The name. Let's be honest, that's most of the Submariner's price.
  • Resale. A Sub holds its value like almost nothing else. These won't. The flip side: you're risking far less money.
  • The bracelet and clasp. Rolex's Glidelock clasp adjusts on the fly. Few rivals come close.
  • Ceramic. Only some of these have a ceramic bezel, which won't fade or scratch.

So which one?

Want it to feel like a luxury watch? Tudor Black Bay 58. Want the best value? Longines HydroConquest. Want something that's yours and not a copy of anything? Oris Aquis. On a budget? Christopher Ward or Lorier.

Weighing the Tudor against the Omega instead? Tom did that comparison. And if you want to go cheaper still, he also has the best dive watches under $1,000.

Dave Kowalski is a pen name of The Watch Quest editorial team. Opinions are based on the published specs, the brand's own information and the watch's reputation, not a long-term test.

All buying guides