Tudor Black Bay 58 vs Omega Seamaster 300M: which dive watch to buy

By Tom Hargreaves, Falmouth, Cornwall ยท Updated

These two get compared more than any other pair of dive watches, and for good reason. Both come from brands with real diving history, both are serious tools and both sit in the same price bracket, give or take. They're also very different watches on the wrist. Here's how they stack up.

Tudor Black Bay 58

Reference
M79030N-0001
Style
Diver
Case diameter
39 mm
Thickness
11.9 mm
Case material
Steel
Crystal
Sapphire
Movement
Automatic (MT5402)
Power reserve
70 hours
Complications
rotating bezel
Water resistance
200 m
Strap or bracelet
Metal
Released
2018
List price
$4,325 to $4,600

Omega Seamaster Diver 300M

Reference
210.30.42.20.01.001
Style
Diver
Case diameter
42 mm
Thickness
13.6 mm
Case material
Steel
Crystal
Sapphire
Movement
Automatic (8800)
Power reserve
55 hours
Complications
date, rotating bezel, helium valve
Water resistance
300 m
Strap or bracelet
Metal
Released
2018
List price
$5,900 to $6,400

The short answer

If your wrist is under about 17 cm, or you want a watch that looks like the 1950s, buy the Black Bay 58. If you want the more modern, more technical watch with a date and better water resistance, and you have the wrist for 42 mm, buy the Seamaster 300M. Neither is a bad choice. I'd take the Tudor, because I'd rather have a watch that disappears under a wetsuit cuff.

Size and comfort

This is where they differ most. The Tudor is 39 mm and under 12 mm thick, with a lug-to-lug that stays under 48 mm. It wears small and flat. The Omega is 42 mm, 13.6 mm thick, and roughly 50 mm from lug to lug, with a heavier bracelet. On a big wrist it looks right. On a small one, the lugs reach the edges. Try one on before you buy if you can, because this decides it for most people.

Movement and accuracy

Omega's 8800 is a METAS Master Chronometer: tested in the cased watch to 0 to +5 seconds a day and resistant to 15,000 gauss, which means a phone speaker or a magnetic bag clasp won't throw it off. It has 55 hours of reserve and you can see it through the sapphire caseback.

Tudor updated the Black Bay 58 in 2026. The new one has a Master Chronometer movement too, the same 0 to +5 standard, and is a touch slimmer, but its reserve drops from 70 to 65 hours. The table above shows the outgoing version, which most shops and the pre-owned market still have, with its COSC-certified 70-hour movement. Either Tudor beats the Omega on power reserve. Hannah wrote about the update on the blog.

Underwater

The Seamaster is rated to 300 m and has a helium escape valve, which matters to saturation divers and to almost nobody else. The Tudor is rated to 200 m, which is plenty for any recreational diving you'll ever do. The Omega's ceramic bezel won't fade or scratch; the Tudor's aluminium insert will pick up marks over the years, which some people like. Both are perfectly legible, though the Tudor's no-date dial is cleaner.

Price and value

The Omega lists for noticeably more, and it gives you more watch on paper for it: ceramic, a date, more depth, a display back. The Tudor is the better value if what you want is a simple, well-made diver. Both hold their value reasonably well pre-owned, and both are easy to find, which isn't true of the Rolex Submariner they're both measured against. If you're weighing either against that one, our guide to watches like the Submariner for less covers the field.

Who should buy which

  • Black Bay 58: smaller wrists, vintage looks, no date, longest reserve.
  • Seamaster 300M: bigger wrists, modern look, date, ceramic bezel, best accuracy and magnetic resistance.
  • Neither: if you want the same idea for a quarter of the money, see our best dive watches under $1,000.

Tom Hargreaves is a pen name of The Watch Quest editorial team. Opinions are based on the published specs, the brand's own information and the watch's reputation, not a long-term test.

All buying guides