Microbrand alternatives to the Rolex Submariner
By Tom Hargreaves, Falmouth, Cornwall · Updated
I'll say this for the Submariner: it's a properly good dive watch, and it has been for seventy years. What I don't like is paying ten thousand dollars and waiting for a dealer to decide I'm worthy of one. The small brands have spent the last decade building exactly the watch I want instead, and selling it straight to me.
By microbrand I mean a small, usually founder-run company that sells mostly online, in batches, without a dealer network. That means no markup for the shop and no waiting list. It also means some models sell out and you wait for the next batch, and service goes through the brand rather than a local boutique. Fair trade, in my view.
First, the benchmark next to the microbrand I'd buy if I could only have one.
Rolex Submariner No Date
- Reference
- 124060
- Style
- Diver
- Case diameter
- 41 mm
- Thickness
- 12.5 mm
- Case material
- Steel
- Crystal
- Sapphire
- Movement
- Automatic (3230)
- Power reserve
- 70 hours
- Complications
- rotating bezel
- Water resistance
- 300 m
- Strap or bracelet
- Metal
- Released
- 2020
- List price
- $9,300 to $9,650
Lorier Neptune
- Reference
- NEP5-BLK-ND-BRAC
- Style
- Diver
- Case diameter
- 39 mm
- Thickness
- 11.4 mm
- Case material
- Steel
- Crystal
- Sapphire
- Movement
- Automatic (Miyota 9039)
- Power reserve
- 42 hours
- Complications
- rotating bezel
- Water resistance
- 200 m
- Strap or bracelet
- Metal
- Released
- 2025
- List price
- $700
The picks
1. Lorier Neptune: Closest in spirit
- Reference
- NEP5-BLK-ND-BRAC
- Style
- Diver
- Case diameter
- 39 mm
- Thickness
- 11.4 mm
- Case material
- Steel
- Crystal
- Sapphire
- Movement
- Automatic (Miyota 9039)
- Power reserve
- 42 hours
- Complications
- rotating bezel
- Water resistance
- 200 m
- Strap or bracelet
- Metal
- Released
- 2025
- List price
- $700
A married couple in New York making the 1960s Submariner the way people remember it: 39 mm, 11.4 mm thick, no date, 200 m and a warm vintage-style dial. It wears beautifully on a normal wrist. The Miyota movement is no Rolex calibre, but it's dependable and anyone can service it.
2. Baltic Aquascaphe: Best value
- Reference
- AQS-BLK
- Style
- Diver
- Case diameter
- 39 mm
- Thickness
- 12.9 mm
- Case material
- Steel
- Crystal
- Sapphire
- Movement
- Automatic (Miyota 9039)
- Power reserve
- 42 hours
- Complications
- rotating bezel
- Water resistance
- 200 m
- Strap or bracelet
- Metal
- Released
- 2019
- List price
- $650 to $790
French, assembled in Besançon, 39 mm and 200 m with a clean no-date dial. It's less of a Sub copy than the Lorier and more of its own thing, which I like. A very easy watch to wear every day.
3. Halios Seaforth IV: Hardest to get
- Reference
- SEAFORTH-IV
- Style
- Diver
- Case diameter
- 41 mm
- Thickness
- 12.4 mm
- Case material
- Titanium
- Crystal
- Sapphire
- Movement
- Automatic (Sellita SW200-2)
- Power reserve
- 65 hours
- Complications
- rotating bezel
- Water resistance
- 200 m
- Strap or bracelet
- Rubber
- Released
- 2026
- List price
- $765
Jason Lim's Vancouver brand sells out in minutes, and the Seaforth is why. 41 mm, 200 m, a Swiss Sellita with a 65-hour reserve, and the kind of finishing that makes people check the price twice. Join the mailing list and be quick.
4. Vaer D5 Tropic Auto 39: Toughest everyday diver
- Reference
- D5-TR
- Style
- Diver
- Case diameter
- 39 mm
- Thickness
- 12.5 mm
- Case material
- Steel
- Crystal
- Sapphire
- Movement
- Automatic (Miyota 9015)
- Power reserve
- 42 hours
- Complications
- date, rotating bezel
- Water resistance
- 200 m
- Strap or bracelet
- Metal
- Released
- 2025
- List price
- $750
Vaer builds sturdy, no-nonsense watches with a 39 mm case, 200 m and a sapphire crystal. The date and the outdoorsy look make it more of a daily beater than a dress diver. If you'll actually bash it about, this is a good one.
5. Zelos Swordfish 40mm: Cheapest
- Reference
- SWORDFISH-40-SLATE
- Style
- Diver
- Case diameter
- 40 mm
- Thickness
- 12 mm
- Case material
- Steel
- Crystal
- Sapphire
- Movement
- Automatic (Seiko NH35)
- Power reserve
- 41 hours
- Complications
- date, rotating bezel
- Water resistance
- 200 m
- Strap or bracelet
- Metal
- Released
- 2024
- List price
- $399
Elshan Tang's Singapore brand puts sapphire and 200 m on a 40 mm diver for under four hundred dollars. The Seiko movement is basic and the bracelet is fine rather than great, but there's a lot of watch here for the money.
6. Serica 5303-1 Chronometre Plongee: Most refined
- Reference
- 5303-1
- Style
- Diver
- Case diameter
- 39 mm
- Thickness
- 12.2 mm
- Case material
- Steel
- Crystal
- Sapphire
- Movement
- Automatic (Soprod M100)
- Power reserve
- 42 hours
- Complications
- rotating bezel
- Water resistance
- 300 m
- Strap or bracelet
- Metal
- Released
- 2021
- List price
- $1,750 to $1,910
Serica is a Paris brand with a calm, careful design language, and the 5303 is the diver I'd pick if I wanted the Submariner's seriousness without its look. 39 mm, 300 m, and proportions that feel thought through rather than borrowed.
7. Formex Reef 42 Automatic Chronometer: Best movement
- Reference
- 2200.1.6333
- Style
- Diver
- Case diameter
- 42 mm
- Thickness
- 11.4 mm
- Case material
- Steel
- Crystal
- Sapphire
- Movement
- Automatic (Sellita SW300-1 (COSC))
- Power reserve
- 56 hours
- Complications
- date, rotating bezel
- Water resistance
- 300 m
- Strap or bracelet
- Metal
- Released
- 2021
- List price
- $2,085 to $2,230
A Swiss chronometer-certified Sellita with 56 hours of reserve, 300 m, and a case only 11.4 mm thick for its 42 mm. Formex is a small brand from Biel with an engineer's approach. It wears big, so try one if you can.
8. Monta Oceanking: Closest to luxury finish
- Reference
- OCEANKING-BLACK-CER
- Style
- Diver
- Case diameter
- 40.5 mm
- Thickness
- 12 mm
- Case material
- Steel
- Crystal
- Sapphire
- Movement
- Automatic (Monta M-22 (Sellita SW300 base))
- Power reserve
- 56 hours
- Complications
- date, rotating bezel
- Water resistance
- 300 m
- Strap or bracelet
- Metal
- Released
- 2023
- List price
- $2,550
Monta started in St. Louis with the aim of matching Swiss luxury finishing at a lower price, and the Oceanking is where it shows. 300 m, 56 hours, 40.5 mm. It's the most expensive pick here, still about a quarter of the Rolex, and the one a watch person will notice across a room.
What you give up
- Resale. A Submariner holds its value. These won't, though you're risking far less.
- The dealer. No boutique to walk into. Most of these brands offer returns by post and are good about it, but check first.
- Service nearby. The Seiko, Miyota and Sellita movements here can be serviced by almost any watchmaker, which takes most of the sting out of that.
If you'd rather stick with a bigger name, Dave's watches like the Submariner for less covers Tudor, Longines and Oris.
Tom Hargreaves is a pen name of The Watch Quest editorial team. Opinions are based on the published specs, the brand's own information and the watch's reputation, not a long-term test.